Ramblings of my curious mind

For a few days, it seemed the new Palm Pre might have a chance at challenging the iPhone as the smartphone to buy. But with Apple's announcement Monday of the iPhone 3GS, which matches the Pre in price at $199, but has more memory, a video camera and a faster Web-browsing experience than the Pre, the 3GS is the victor for now.

Apple's App Store, with more than 50,000 programs, also ensures the iPhone's continued reign, with it leading all other smartphones in terms of the number and quality of third-party programs, or "apps" available for the device. The Pre, which went on sale Saturday, has a terrific operating system, but an anemic offering for programs through its App Catalog, which had less than two dozen programs available at launch.

Such third-party programs, from utilities to games, make a major difference in the quality of the smartphone experience. The iPhone's "there's an app for that" ad campaign has been satirized, but don't miss the meaning of the message: When, for example, you can not only arrange to rent, but unlock your Zipcar rental vehicle using your iPhone, as you'll be able to do shortly, that's the kind of experience that truly sets a device apart from the rest as remarkable.

Palm says it isn't necessarily looking to grab some of the iPhone's market, but rather to appeal to newer smartphone users who will appreciate Palm's webOS, which does an exceptional job of multitasking and unifying events, e-mails and contacts seamlessly to eliminate hunting for such data.

There is real value in that. But there is so much more in the iPhone as a device, especially with the 3GS's even faster Web experience, billed by Apple as being about twice the speed of the current iPhone. The new phone goes on sale June 19.

Current Analysis consumer devices research director Avi Greengart, who briefly tested the iPhone 3GS against his iPhone 3G at Apple's Worldwide Developers Conference this week, says it is "significantly faster and noticeably so" than either the 3G or the Pre.

"There are some things on the Pre that are somewhat sluggish, but with the Pre, you're keeping multiple applications open and swiping between them," he said, which takes more memory, and hence, a bit more time.

Palm has done an outstanding job with the Pre, released last Saturday, its first phone to use the company's new webOS operating system. It lets users flick, or "throw," as Palm puts it, programs off the screen with abandon while still running other programs, from e-mail to music.

The Pre is relatively easy to use, but the iPhone remains easier, with fewer touchscreen gestures to learn and its single home button on the front of the device as the entrance and exit to all programs.

"All phones are becoming smart, but some are Einsteins," wrote Forrester analyst Ian Fogg in a recent report about smartphones. Feel free to call the iPhone "Albert Senior" and the Pre "Albert Junior."

With Apple adding the long overdue copy-and-paste feature to all iPhones as part of its 3.0 software release June 17, the addition of a video cam and upgrade of its 2-megapixel camera to 3 megapixels in the 3GS, the iPhone continues to be a more appealing device.

Here's a look at some of the differences between the Pre and the iPhone 3GS:

Dimensions
The Pre is 3.9 inches high, 2.3 inches wide, .67 of an inch thick. It weighs 4.76 ounces. The iPhone 3GS is 4.5 inches high, 2.4 inches wide, .48 of an inch thick. It weighs 4.8 ounces (The iPhone 3G is 4.7 ounces).

Ergonomics/screen/keyboard
The Pre is shorter than the iPhone but it's also more "grippable" and more likely to comfortably wind up in a pant pocket than the iPhone, which has an almost two-dimensional look and feel to it. Both phones are comfortable to hold in hand.

You can use the Pre's slightly angled, slide-out keyboard to rest the phone between your ear and chin when you're on a call. It's definitely handier than trying to position the iPhone the same way and accidentally hitting the "end" or "mute" button on the screen.

The screens on both devices are excellent, with a resolution of 480-by-320 pixels. The iPhone has a larger display of 3.5 inches, compared to the Pre's 3.1 inches, and the larger screen is a plus for Web browsing, e-mail, opening attachments and playing games.

The Palm's keyboard is best used with fingernails rather than fingers. It's a real QWERTY keyboard, but it's tiny and not as good as those on most BlackBerrys. Palm has added some nice touches by having stand-alone keys for the "@" symbol and the period, frequently used characters in e-mail. It's a time-saver not to have to hit an "Alt" key and a capital letter to get those characters inserted.

The iPhone's on-screen keyboard takes some getting used to, but is quite responsive, especially with its feature of enlarging letters as you select them so you can make sure you're hitting the right ones.

[source]